Header
The Bureaucrat as Hero
By Tom Shoop | Friday, June 22, 2007  |  04:01 PM

Christopher Hayes of The Nation takes up one of life's most thankless tasks: defending the bureaucracy. Given the nature of the publication that his piece appears in, it's not surprising that it's presented in the context of a searing critique of the current administration. But whatever you think of the politics, this is an impassioned defense, presented with panache. An excerpt:

A funny thing has happened over the past six years. At a time when the press failed to check a reactionary Administration, when the opposition party all too often chose timidity, it was the lowly and anonymous bureaucrats, clad in rumpled suits, ID badges dangling from their necks, who, in their own quiet, behind-the-scenes way, took to the ramparts to defend the integrity of the American system of government.

It was the midlevel intelligence professionals in the CIA whose expertise led them to argue that Iraq had no means of acquiring nuclear material; it was the planners and country experts at the State Department who prepared a 1,200-page document about postwar Iraq outlining in depressing detail the many challenges and brutalizing exigencies our occupying forces now face. It was professional scientists in the bowels of the Environmental Protection Agency who pushed their reports warning of the effects of climate change, only to have them censored and purged. It was concerned and conscientious spooks and cryptographers at the National Security Agency who contacted reporters to raise alarms about the warrantless wiretapping of Americans. It was a midlevel career bureaucrat at the Department of Education named Jon Oberg who spent his own time--nights and weekends--studying the student loan program and discovered that taxpayers were being ripped off by private lenders to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars.

(Hat tip to my colleague at The Atlantic Online, Matthew Yglesias.)



Comments


In March 2001 I arrived at the Federal Executive Institute for the LDS course. After the administrative stuff we heard opening remarks from the staff. I was surprised by how frank they were.

"Politics is broken. It's up to you to carry on."

A year later I found myself transferred into that bottomless pit known as the Transportation Security Administration. To quote from my retirement speech in 2006:

"You would think that in a time of national emergency those in authority would turn to highly experienced veterans who had seen many crises and aquitted themselves with distinction. Well, people were sacked for saying so. And they reached out to experts from Disney World. There is nothing so terrible as ignorance in action. What followed can best be described as genetic deficiency on steroids. Or evolution without natural selection. To find yourself a despised outcast in a sea of carpetbaggers is an ill met reward for loyalty, perserverance, and long service of selfless devotion."

I knew then and now that I was speaking for many.

Karl Shrum  | Sunday, June 24, 2007 |  01:10 PM




Post a comment



ABOUT THIS BLOG


Executive Editor Tom Shoop takes a look at news and events affecting the federal bureaucracy, from the perspective of a longtime observer of government.

SEARCH THIS BLOG