GovernmentExecutive.com

As someone within the Bush Administration who has actually proven himself in his field, I am surprised that someonse like Mr. Dickinson, a prior actual firefighter, would say such a thing. When I was in the Navy as a lead firefighter aboard an aircraft carrier, I always appreciated the help and assistance that our fellow shipmates offered during emergencies, many of who were not actually 'assigned' to the firefighting team. So long as they understood that they were de facto helping hands that supported the 'real' trained firefighters, everything always worked out OK. I am sure that under able on-site leadership from fire chiefs and police officers, the same can occur in the civilian setting. Besides, it's in and American's DNA to help in emergency situations.

I believe it was an off-duty Marine who saved that policeman at the World Trade Center. While he may not be typically considered a "civilian", he wouldn't have been allowed to assist in the rescue if this ID program were in place. Mr. Dickinson needs to realize that disaster scenes are the breeding grounds for heroes... whether in uniform or not. We are American's! We don't back down from adversity. First responders are not the only people with specialized training. If the Fire Dept. can't deal with them effectively, use a bullhorn! Don't spend countless dollars on another "badge" and tons of red tape for a system that is virtually un-enforceable! Do you think anyone was checking for the badges of the boat operators after Katrina?